Skip to main content

The fallacy of assumptions

Generalisations and assumptions  shouldn't be made in haste. They might give rise to partisanship, racism, bigotry and ethnic cleansing. Human beings irrespective of common denomination are unique in themselves.

What is common however is the innate nature of human beings to have a fear of failure at surviving.  No one is sure about anything in this world.  No one can predict the future.  No matter how much mathematics is used, no one can predict an event born out of randomness.

It is because of this uncertainty and fear, human beings have the tendency of staying in groups.  The more the size of the group the better is the chance of survival and lower is the risk of damage from randomness.

However,  the group should hold a common belief. Now beliefs can be several. The survival of that group is based on how much  control it can have over individuals at imposing a fixed common set of beliefs. 

The group can even have various tools to control the beliefs of individuals.  Those tools can range from a holy book, a messenger of god to diktats and guns. After all it is the survival of the group which is important.

Now there can arise some groups which over the time let themselves split up into smaller groups for the lack of proper control, mainly on the control in the belief in a single God.

Does that change the attitude of individuals belonging to those smaller groups?  Yes, to some extent that changes.  The individuals gradually become vulnerable to the damages caused by randomness and to oppression as well.

But once in a while a leader gets born. The leader who understands the need of forming a single homogeneous group with a common set of beliefs.  Under his command,  smaller groups can again come together. The leader can use the same tools to govern that group.  That group might just become big enough to overpower other smaller groups.

Will the attitude of the individuals change at that time? Yes, they will gradually become more intolerant and ambitious. They might try to become the avengers of history's prejudice and injustice.

Generalisations and assumptions are  dangerous things. They might give rise to partisanship, racism, bigotry and ethnic cleansing. 


  1. The group should have a common belief, you say. So let the whole of India believe that Modi is the present incarnation of Brahma. Will that solve the problem?

    I think groups belong to the mediocre. Do you find intelligent people in any group? Sine I am an idiot I don't know what intelligent people really do, but just asking you since you are intelligent. :)

    1. Sir, I am idiot enough at failing to convey the sarcasm I wanted to present here.

      A common belief strengthens a group to an extent of making it a remote controlled bomb.

      Hindus are tolerant? Now that's an assumption and how assumptions can go wrong can be seen in recent times.

      Modi is the incarnation of brahma? That's funny. I thought he is the prophet as was predicted in holy books.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Analysis of Sita - Warrior of Mithila

Ramayana and Mahabharata, to many, are not epic fictions but holy books! So much holy, that some in their blind faith go on to the extreme extent of distorting geographical locations to suit the written words of those fictions. So much holy to some, that decades of politics has been played on the peculiar nuances of those holier than thou texts.

In the midst of such lame conundrums created off the mythological books, Mr. Amish Tripathi has dared to weave fictions out of the fictitious, although respectable, religious sagas of Gods and Goddesses of the Hindu religion.

That the books have not faced the anger of saffron adorned bhakts talks a lot about the intelligence of Mr. Tripathi with which he has handled the stories using kid gloves. His latest book on the Ram chandra series, Sita warrior of Mithila, has not disappointed the religious pandits a bit, it seems.

It would not be fair on my part to expect a Salman Rushdie style fiction from Amish Tripathi. Not everyone wants to be a Rush…

A letter with no words

What can I give you more But a letter with no words a blank sheet of memories!
I thought of infusing the page with some notes some notes of music that my heart cries But what can I give you more but a silence of my sound!
I thought of enclosing some moonlight on it some shy reflection of my dreams that I once dreamt with you But what can I give you now but a darkness of miseries
I thought of giving you a fresh page with newly gathered hopes that I endeavoured to have without you But what can I give you now but a crumbled folio with creases of agonies
What can I give you more But a letter with no words a wasted sheet of memories!

Being an audience to the play!

Before the start of this post, I would like to pose a question to you:

Does free will exist?

I came across an article which actually talks about how it is our neurons which does the action. What we are is because of our neurons and how it fires up in the brain, moment to moment! Now, that's an interesting and also scientifically proven thing to ponder upon. 

Given a stimulus, millions of neurons start working up their way through various synapses across thousands of complex topologies which in a matter of micro seconds recalls our past events and analyses our present situation to hint the brain to act out an output accordingly.
Now this output that our brain directs our body to perform can be considered to be an identity that we assume for that stimulus. That is, we assume a certain role against that stimulus in this world, that Shakespeare considered as a stage. 
All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players 
 I have had a journey of a year in this blogosphere.…

A curious case of alternate ending to a poem

"Everything that you need to know is there in the NCERT text books. You do not need to go for other fat and ugly books" exhorted our science teacher in his typical assamese accented english which most of us, the people of Assam, carry with an impetuous pride. But we found it hard to believe. The questions were framed quite oddly in those books, the concepts were never explained elaborately, pages were too much colorful and the language was an enigma to most of us!

We never read NCERT books for our courses. We would have reference books by S.Chands and Dhanpats for all purpose weathers. Years later, I would realise that life never presents a reference book for all the mysterious problems! We, now, have to read life in between the lines!

It is perhaps the lack of the ability to read in between the lines that led me to give an alternate ending to a very beautiful narrative poem with an even more interesting title  Night of the Scorpion by Nissim Ezekiel. In an intermittent con…

Random events, a pigeon and superstition

I talk a lot about randomness. The first post on my blog was about randomness. I am intrigued by the randomness. Why? Because I refuse to believe in god! If god cannot give me the answers, then perhaps it is the randomness of events that might give me the solace, or so I think!
Is tossing a coin a random event? We think it is. It is for this randomness that we toss a coin to decide things like the first to play in a game. But is it truly random?
Tossing a coin is a mechanical process. It is a physics and hence can always be modeled mathematically. The output as a head or tail can be determined to accuracy if one knows the initial position of the coin, the velocity of the throw, the direction of the throw, the wind direction, exact gravitational acceleration, mass of the coin, centre of gravity of the coin, angular momentum etc. Yes, one can always predict the outcome of the tossing of a coin, if one knows the details of these parameters and many others which are not known to me but are …

A ditched girl getting Bayesian'ed'

I am getting late for my work. But while getting ready, my stream of consciousness suddenly questioned me on probability and so I thought better to write it out before I get myself involved in the filth of humanity.

It so happened, that I being a regular reader of blogs, specially Tomichan's, happened to comment on one of his posts where he claimed that the chance of a two time ditched women not getting ditched for the third time is nil not because of bayesian probability but because of her own past experiences.

I think a lot. And I hate it when those thoughts after sometime become foggy, confusing and incoherent. And so I tend to run away from most of the thoughts prefering, for most of the time, being ignorant.

Yes, I get myself in the state of ignorance, for my limited thinking capacity cannot comprehend the enormity of truth. It just cannot. Perhaps with age I will be able to, but I am not sure of that either.

So, yes.. about state of ignorance. Upon some thinking, I am claiming t…

Moksha and Parallel universe- A hypothesis

Moksha and Parallel universe- A hypothesis
Buddhism is the closest atheistic religion that I have ever come across, although there could be still many which follows atheism (Jainism?). The core philosophy of Buddhism is not its sitting meditation, not its mystic chants and not even living an austere life but following each and every second of one’s life in the present moment. Yes, you are right. It is as simple as that. Just live your life in the present moment and according to Buddha you might get nirvana! But how? But why? And what the hell is that nirvana? All I would want to have is a peace of mind and not attain a hypothetical state called Nirvana, although the name sounds too cool! (My favorite band is Nirvana to begin with!).
I think myself as a rational, a reasonable and a logical being. One reason of believing in Buddha and his doctrines is his nonchalant way of evading the question of god. As if to him it doesn’t matter! Just follow the damn- live in the present moment- princip…

A promiscuous affair with 50 books

The modern reading screens have made me habituated to reading texts without the need to feel the sensuous touch of pages. Be it the monitors of computers, screens of smart phones or the amazing kindles I have had the experience and a gradual inclination towards the I-don't-care-where-to-read attitude when it comes to books.

However, my experience with Kindle has been amazing; with no glare on the screen and a natural e ink display, it feels like reading actual book albeit with a digital barrier.

So, when I noticed a kindle book containing 50 masterpieces from Dante Alighieri  to Oscar Wilde with a little bit of James Joyce, Dickens, Victor Hugo , Dostoevsky and Gogol at a cost of INR 77 which is cheaper than a normal Chetan Bhagat's book, I didn't think twice to buy it immediately.

You might be curious to know the exact list of books that I got at this jaw dropping price. So here is the list. Hold your breath :

- The Divine Comedy [Dante Alighieri]  - Emma [Jane Austen] - Persu…

The mask

You have thirteen missed calls from 4 contacts, displayed was the notification on his mobile.

He saw that but failed to see the need. The need of calling them back. Not that he was irritated with them. Not that he was having a bad day. Not that he was depressed.

"Why do they call me so much?" he asked himself. However he knows that of all the billions of people on this earth those four sapiens on his contact list are the ones who care about him, who think about him, who worry for him.

"But I don't want to be noticed" he argued "not even by those four people". One doesn't always need people around one to go on with one's life. He didn't need anyone around him, psychologically, at that moment nor at most of the time. He wanted to be ignored. He wanted to be left with his own device.

Human beings are supposed to be social, argued his mind. For how long would you be able to go on like this. For how long?

"I want to become obsolete" he tal…

Ek paye nupur amar- the song and a memory

A song popped up in the IP messenger of my computer. The sender was named DG. Of course, I knew the guy. He was a Bangladeshi citizen who had came to our college in the international exchange program that our institute followed.  Our institute housed students from Bangladesh, Afghanistan and even Uganda. In a way, this was a great opportunity for Indian students to have an experience of diversity on top of our Indian diversity.

The song was named as "ek paye nupur.mp3". Back in those days, we didn't have whatsapp messengers! We didn't even have high speed internet.  What we had, however,  was an intricate LAN connection which poked its nose inside each and every single room of each and every hostel that was established inside our institute campus. IP messenger,  in which the song popped up, was on of those softwares which worked because of the interconnected LAN system of our hostels.

The DG named guy, the Bangladeshi one, had his room diagonally opposite to mine. G…