Skip to main content

Random events, a pigeon and superstition

I talk a lot about randomness. The first post on my blog was about randomness. I am intrigued by the randomness. Why? Because I refuse to believe in god! If god cannot give me the answers, then perhaps it is the randomness of events that might give me the solace, or so I think!

Is tossing a coin a random event? We think it is. It is for this randomness that we toss a coin to decide things like the first to play in a game. But is it truly random?

Tossing a coin is a mechanical process. It is a physics and hence can always be modeled mathematically. The output as a head or tail can be determined to accuracy if one knows the initial position of the coin, the velocity of the throw, the direction of the throw, the wind direction, exact gravitational acceleration, mass of the coin, centre of gravity of the coin, angular momentum etc. Yes, one can always predict the outcome of the tossing of a coin, if one knows the details of these parameters and many others which are not known to me but are crucial to the outcome.

But why do we consider even a simple tossing of a coin as a random event even when we can formulate a mathematical model to know the output? It is because there are so many factors that affect its outcome, that considering all the factors in each and every toss of a coin is a near impossibility! And we assume that it is a random event, we assume that randomness has played its trick to the outcome of the coin!!

What about events that happen to a person in the real world? Well, there are infinite such factors governing the outcome of human beings as compared to the countable factors for a lifeless coin. The one major problem that we face is our consciousness!  We have a consciousness much broader than any other animal.

Scientists love to observe a simplified model of a complex system.  Hence, to observe the effect of a medicine they use lab rats!

Psychologist B.F.Skinner was no different at that aspect.  He chose a pigeon for an experiment.  He knew that there are lots of factors that affect the behavior and hence the outcome of an animal. To eliminate such factors, he placed the pigeon in a box. The box was attached to a mechanism which delivers the food at a regular interval.  The regular interval of food was the only factor directed at the pigeon.

The behavior of the pigeon to just one factor was amazing!  The pigeon started associating the outcome of food with the action they had been performing at that time of the outcome.  To give an instance,  one bird started to turn anti clockwise assuming that this behavior would give them the food.

This is called as the pigeon superstition. Of course,  the pigeon model used is the simplest of the models and the delivery of the outcome was set at a regular interval.

Suppose we replace the bird with a human being,  an educated human being,  and start giving him food at an irregular interval!  If the person in the experiment is hungry to the extent of death, my guess would be that he would also start performing actions which to him delivers the outcome of food.

Suppose we replace an educated but an atheistic person, instead, inside the box. What would he do to get the food delivered?  Would he just wait for the mercy of the irregular interval of time at which the food is supplied?  An educated person with a background of arts or science with an experience of technological gadgets would just wait upon the whimsical nature of the food delivery mechanism? What would he do? ( No he cannot see the mechanism of food delivery from inside the box! I know you would come up with smart answers, but let's just assume that he cannot do anything smart!)

What would he do?

Perhaps we can have a scientist who would name his actions thereafter as the Atheist superstition.

Superstitions are there to exist.  It is the superstition which eventually gave birth to religion and God! But, superstition is there to exist, in spite of education,  in spite of technological advancement, in spite of mathematical models of coin tossing.

Superstition is there to exist unless we do accept the randomness of events as it is, unless we embrace the absurdity of events as it is!

Comments

  1. Your final verdict put me quite at ease. I have embraced absurdity and hence I love happily without superstitions. Nothing surprises me anymore because I have embraced the essential randomness that is at work in life.

    An example from personal life may make it clearer. I had a very happy job in Delhi. I had planned to retire at the ripe age of 60 from that job. But totally unexpectedly and extremely randomly came a godman who bought up my school and dismissed the staff and students summarily and cleverly. My world turned upside down. Without rhyme or reason. I could never have expected such callousness from a religious person and his chelas. The evil that these people displayed was kaleidoscopic. It took me six months to overcome the depression it landed me in. I could never regain my trust in people after that.

    Superstition is also a trust. My trust has been destroyed. I embrace the absurdity of all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There was a poem in our course at school. Perhaps you would know the exact name of the poem, which I had forgotten by now. There, the man was shown to be a rational being. But when his wife had got bitten by the scorpion, he much against his principles, got succumbed to the superstition of finding the scorpion that bit his wife.

      Adversity in human life makes a person weak or strong. Embracing absurdity requires extreme courage and strength. The easier way out is to hide under the warm comfort of God and Godmen!

      I have a huge respect for you because of the ways you have chosen to deal with your sudden adversity. I think your short stories are a way to deal with and make sense of such randomness.

      Delete
    2. Nissim Ezekiel's Night of the Scorpion. Yes, that's a good example. Such faith makes life easier. I'm incapable of it. Such was my life.

      Delete
    3. I just read the poem again. I wonder what made me give the poem an alternate ending. Thanks for the name. Now I see how the poet presented his entire village as religious and superstitious who were up against one rational and a sceptic.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Light knows Independence

"Baba" called Asmaan to his father, "When are they giving me the books. I miss my studies already"
His father had a small shop of second hand books. Books don't die, he believed. They don't have a shelf life. People die. They die of poverty - hunger, malnutrition, illiteracy, unemployment, politics and flood. But books don't.
But he was proved wrong when flood stormed, like an unwarranted storm, a storm which gulped down everything like an ugly demon never satisfied of preying. His tiny heart seemed to miss those blotted ink marks of yellowing pages. The roaring water not only drowned his abode but also his heart which kindled a dream to soar high, higher than the cupid's arrow for he had heard his devotion to books attest - "the sky is the limit".
Ironically, the only thing he could look upto through the shabby refuge camp was a gloomy sky which held no promises. But he held on to the promises which comes like the same deluge inundating…

The invitation letter

If you look closely at him, you will see a labyrinth of lines. Curved lines. Faded lines. Intersecting lines. Lines which formed through ages of anguish. Valleys formed through the concealed dry tears of loneliness. Marched, the invisible soldiers of agonies marched through those valleys. Left . Right. Left and shoot! Killing the unarmed beggars of happiness on the road.

His clothed hands, clothed with loose folded, blemished and wrinkled brown skin, held an invitation letter.

What you see would be a painting- a dilapidated wooden house, shades of yellow and red enveloping the background, a recliner in the centre and the old man sitting on it holding the letter. The hands with clothed and wrinkled memories were the only thing which remained unsteady in that painting.

He would not know what was written in that letter. The boundaries were becoming addled to him. The black ink and white spaces knew no boundaries, his memories and dreams knew no demarcations. His memories were dreams …

Kafka, the monsters and the nameless.

Your ticket has been confirmed. Seat no. 13W. Have a safe and a happy journey.
A part of the confirmation mail screamed at me. Why do they even attempt at writing the same "safe and happy journey" message to everyone. What is so happy about a journey, I thought.
My bus was meant to depart at 5 a.m from the terminal. I woke up much earlier than that. When you have ghosts of past haunting your dreams, the morning becomes the end of your darkness. The mind fears those monsters with such trepidations that the cobwebs of the nightmares have to be broken by the dawn of new rays, new hopes and new aspirations.
From the corner of my mind I can see those monsters seeking the darkness that I have been trying to thwart. "Thou shall not find light", they seem to say even in the midst of the morning light. Going to a new place would help me find my light, I thought and so did the doctor, with a bag full of anti darkness pills, concur.
It didn't take me time to pack my ba…

A dead clock

Where did my voice fall? Cobwebs on the wall With a dead clock and  lizards crawl Staring at me, making me so small So small!
The dawns and the dusks The days and nights in this dust Looking for my voice, used to trust Looked at my mind, oh a rust!

Waiting for you here
Amidst my layers, within my fear
Steps away from my door, you there?
You there?

Where did my voice go?
A dead clock or is it slow?
Oh! I feel so low
Feel so low

Ma rulzzz !!!

I have a firm belief that communication is an engagement of both the listener and the speaker in a clear, concised and convenient form, where the roles of the speaker and listener should be interchanged in accordance to the context of the conversation and it needs to occur naturally without anyone imposing the other to remain in his/her previous role.
Communication uses tools which forms the basis of language. A language, just like evolution of species, has been evolved through a myriad of civilizations right from the beginning of early man.
Communication undoubtedly has been the only sole means for the survival of homo sapiens on a planet which doesn't treat anyone with niceties. Nature is cruel to everyone and to not communicate with others leads to the natural regression towards extinction.
We have seen communication in the form of cave paintings which shows the human tendency to record events for the present community of human beings and also for the posterity.
But as the civ…

What is self confidence?

What is self confidence?


It is not about the desperation to get something anyhow by any means of any hook or crook.

It is about knowing fully at the onset that you will fail. You will fail miserably with each and every step but yet it's about having a belief that you will be able to make it.

It's not about being intelligent or genius or clever or extrovert .

It is about how far you are willing to push yourself towards the edge of the insanity.

It is not about finding an easy way out

It is about experiencing the path that you took in the journey and making the best out of it.

You might never make it large but you can die trying.  You can have a satisfaction of being courageous at the adverse situations in life.

Life is composed of time. A man made concept of suggesting that the entropy of the universe is increasing incessantly.

No one can stop the entropy, no one can stop the chaos and no one can stop the random events thrown at you.

If it throws you a stone, it will be your …

Brevity

Brevity


Brevity, that is so hard to find my feelings and my emotions my love and my affections Oh I go so blind for your love in my mind
Brevity, that is so hard to find my feelings and my endearment my love and my sentiment Oh I go so inclined for your love on my line
Brevity, that is so hard to find my feelings and my passion my love and my devotion oh I go so behind for your love is so maligned
And I resign And I go behind I am so blind your love's maligned And I go behind And I resign

The disease of oblomovka and the boulder of Sisyphus

What does he run after? What does he want from his life? What is his true calling in his life?

Almost hundred pages are spent showing him lying on his bed. Those pages depict how he never steps out of his bed to enter into the rat race of the mundane life. He has a plot of land somewhere in the country side and when an ominous letter reaches his bed, he starts planning to take matters in his hand. He resolves to put an end to the financial crisis he might suffer if he continues to stay on his bed. But can it not wait till he rests his neck on the pillow for sometime. And thus he dozes off to sleep and the letter gets dusted with his intermittent cycle of sleep and resting of his neck.

Oblomov, the protagonist of the novel Oblomov, represents the epitome of slothfulness of mankind. We all at some point in our lives have suffered from the disease of slothfulness, a trait of human beings which disinclines one to exert his energy over trivial matters.

Everything to Oblomov is trivial. The th…

By the virtue and vice of being Selfish

I am selfish. I do not feel any shame to admit this virtue. I agree with the concept proposed by Ayn Rand in Fountainhead. To seek happiness for one's self, to be self respecting, to be self supporting, to not to sacrifice my self, at the cost of my happiness, to others and never to allow others to sacrifice their self for my cause, is what being selfish means to me.

Yes, I am selfish. And when I help others by going out of my way, I do that for my own selfish reasons. The reasons range from feeling a sense of happiness to feeling a sense of superiority. But I do have my own reasons for my altruism. And hence even my altruism has that hint of selfishness.

Yes, I condone selfishness. Each individual must be selfish on the definition of Ayn Rand's for our society to advance. And hence, I do not consider this virtue of selfishness as a vice. To think for one's self is, in all its worldly definition, the most selfless act.

So what is your take on the word selfish? I will be more …

A letter with no words

What can I give you more But a letter with no words a blank sheet of memories!
I thought of infusing the page with some notes some notes of music that my heart cries But what can I give you more but a silence of my sound!
I thought of enclosing some moonlight on it some shy reflection of my dreams that I once dreamt with you But what can I give you now but a darkness of miseries
I thought of giving you a fresh page with newly gathered hopes that I endeavoured to have without you But what can I give you now but a crumbled folio with creases of agonies
What can I give you more But a letter with no words a wasted sheet of memories!